Slow and steady wins the race, and self storage — an industry that quite literally carries its “home” on its back — proved the point again last year. While the number of transactions barely moved (up just 1% year over year), the value of those deals climbed sharply. Total transaction volume rose 39% from 2024 to nearly $5 billion in 2025, pointing to sustained confidence in the sector’s long-term value.
In 2025, the average sale price per square foot climbed 12% compared to 2024, while the total square footage traded expanded by 13%, showcasing that the continued appetite for larger facilities and portfolio acquisitions has not yet been fully sated. Much of the industry’s backbone still comes from smaller operators and independent owners – the traditional “mom-and-pop” facilities that make up the majority of properties across the country.
However, institutional players continue to shape pricing trends. Real estate investment trusts accounted for over 170 acquisitions, representing 18% of all transactions, with the rest split between storage companies and smaller operators. Among the major institutional buyers, Public Storage, Extra Space Storage, CubeSmart and National Storage Affiliates were present front and center for the trade-off. Notably, REITs also were willing to pay more when acquiring assets. Facilities purchased by REIT buyers averaged $153 per square foot, compared to $111 per square foot for non-REIT buyers.
Top states for self storage sales in 2025
A large share of self storage deal activity gravitated toward the Sunbelt, where population growth and steady housing turnover keep demand for storage space consistently high. Florida alone accounted for nearly $770 million in sales across 91 transactions, making it the most active market in the country.
Further west, California continued to attract investor attention, with roughly $614 million in transactions across 70 deals. Even with higher development barriers and pricing levels, buyers remain drawn to the state’s dense urban markets where storage demand tends to always find fertile soil to expand. Georgia also saw notable momentum with $359 million traded across 51 deals, while Tennessee and South Carolina added meaningful volume across the broader Southeast.
In the meantime, New York recorded some of the highest valuations in the dataset, averaging $269 per square foot, further cementing how land scarcity around New York City and its tightly built suburban corridors continues to push prices upward for existing facilities. New Jersey followed a similar trajectory, combining $262 million in transaction volume with pricing levels at $163 per square foot.
Institutional capital remained active across many of the top-performing markets. REIT buyers accounted for roughly $1.48 billion in acquisitions across 173 transactions, with the largest share directed to Florida at $362 million. New Jersey and Texas also attracted significant REIT investment, while Nevada, California, and Georgia rounded out the list of states that saw consistent interest from large institutional buyers.
Highest price per square foot deals
The Big Apple defines the 2025 high-water mark
This year’s most expensive self storage transactions clustered in markets where development remains constrained and population density continues to push demand upward. In these locations, limited land availability and strict zoning conditions act as a natural ceiling on new supply, allowing pricing to climb well above national averages.
New York City ranked first, with average sale prices reaching roughly $533 per square foot.
Top 10 Priciest Self Storage Markets Across the Country
California markets also featured prominently among the highest-priced transactions. Temecula ($363 per square foot), Palm Desert ($351), South San Francisco ($349), Costa Mesa (about $348), and Sonoma ($304) all ranked among the top-tier markets. Beyond the coast, a handful of secondary markets also posted strong price levels. Bethlehem, GA ($358 per square foot) set itself apart as one of the highest-priced non-coastal locations, while Lakewood, NJ ($324) and Provo, UT ($310) reflected similar dynamics in areas where supply remains limited relative to growing demand.
In supply-constrained coastal markets, REITs tended to pay noticeably more per square foot than private buyers, pointing to a stronger interest for high-quality assets in locations with lasting long-term appeal.
New Jersey was prominent in this regard, with REIT-backed acquisitions averaging about $226 per square foot, compared to roughly $109 per square foot for non-REIT transactions. Florida followed a similar pattern, where REIT pricing averaged around $172 per square foot, versus approximately $100 for private buyers. In development-friendly markets, however, the gap between buyer types tended to narrow. For example, in Illinois, non-REIT acquisitions averaged about $95 per square foot, while REIT purchases came in slightly higher at around $106, indicating more comparable pricing across asset classes.
2026 outlook in self storage
Targeted investment follows 2025 sales momentum as demand pressures build
After a strong, high-value 2025, the self storage sector is entering 2026 on more deliberate footing. Investment activity has picked back up, but the pace is no longer driven by rapid expansion. Instead, capital is being deployed more selectively, with a clear focus on markets that offer either sustained growth or long-term pricing power.
Early signals suggest that consolidation will remain a defining theme. In March, Public Storage agreed to acquire National Storage Affiliates in an all-stock deal valued at about $10.5 billion – underscoring the industry’s tilt toward scale. With the transaction expected to close in the third quarter, the deal highlights continued institutional confidence in self storage, particularly in high-growth Sunbelt regions.
At the market level, two core forces continue to shape investment strategies: growth and scarcity. Sunbelt metros are drawing capital on the back of population gains and steady housing turnover, while coastal markets are maintaining premium valuations due to limited supply and high barriers to entry. Institutional buyers are sustaining pricing at the top end of the market, while private investors remain active in regions where development and repositioning opportunities are more accessible. Overall, the outlook points to a sector that is stabilizing rather than slowing — one where fewer, larger deals and more targeted strategies are likely to define the investment landscape in 2026.
Methodology
This analysis was done by StorageCafe, an online platform that provides storage unit listings across the nation. The data on property sales, self storage prices and self storage inventory was taken from Yardi Matrix, StorageCafe’s sister division and a business development and asset management tool for brokers, sponsors, banks and equity sources underwriting investments in the multifamily, office, industrial and self storage sectors.
To identify the top cities by total sales volume and square footage, as well as the highest-value sales transactions, we analyzed all U.S. cities for which sales data was available. We considered the entire year of 2025. Due to the nature of real estate transactions, not all property sales have disclosed prices. For transactions where pricing information was available, we calculated the sale price per square foot by dividing the total reported sales price of those properties by their total square footage. All figures related to facility size refer to total square footage rather than rentable square footage. While we have made every effort to ensure the accuracy of the data, figures are based on available records and may be subject to revisions or updates.
Related: Westport Properties Acquires FL Self Storage Facility


