Featured Partners

apvcoatings logo

FSU Logo

Adart

Hunter logo

LVC Logo

Wolverine Construction

new logo

Succession is the Real Crisis Facing the Trades

Succession is the Real Crisis Facing the Trades

For most business owners in the construction and trades, the hardest decision isn’t starting the company. It’s building a company that outlasts your time as the owner-operator.

Founders spend decades building crews, earning customer trust, and putting their name on the line with every job. When retirement comes into view, the decision rarely feels clean or simple. Instead, it creates tension. Owners often find themselves weighing two competing paths: The buyer with money in the bank versus the best-suited leader for the business.

Price matters, but most founders understand that what happens after the sale—to employees, customers and their own reputation—matters just as much.

For Erik Hansen, the former owner of Green Way Painting, he was considering shutting the doors prior to finding the right operator. In his words, “We were most concerned about the owner or who could continue it on. The boots on the ground mattered. I wasn’t going to risk it. Our reputation means that much to us.”

Owners aren’t just selecting a buyer. They’re choosing who will be responsible for their employees, their customers, and the reputation they’ve spent a lifetime building after they’re gone.

In today’s market, ownership is increasingly determined by who can pay the most, not who is best equipped to lead. That disconnect defines the real crisis facing the trades.

Why Local Ownership Has Historically Worked in the Trades

Contracting businesses have always depended on local trust. In smaller towns, especially, these companies are built through face-to-face relationships formed over years, not quarters. That trust compounds slowly, earned job by job and referral by referral. Word of mouth doesn’t scale quickly, but it lasts.

Owners play an active role in shaping culture, standards, and expectations in ways that directly influence results. Those dynamics matter in an economy where small businesses make up 99% of all firms and employ nearly half of the workforce.

Employee retention in the trades is closely tied to leadership continuity and credibility. Crews don’t work for a brand alone. They work for a leader they trust to make fair decisions under pressure. Customer loyalty follows a similar logic. Clients value knowing who is accountable when something goes wrong and who stands behind the work when it does.

Local ownership isn’t a sentimental preference. It functions as an operational advantage. These businesses act as economic anchors that sustain employment, spending, and stability in the communities where people live and work.

How Private Equity Became the Default Buyer

Many owners are nearing retirement age without formal succession plans in place. Most never intended to sell their businesses, leaving ownership transition unaddressed for most of the company’s life.

In many cases, owners would rather sell internally, and to someone who already knows the business. Unfortunately, intent alone doesn’t close transactions. Capital does. That doesn’t make private equity villains, but it does make them the only buyers consistently equipped to close.

Internal successors face these structural constraints: limited personal liquidity and little experience executing acquisition deals. Access to institutional or acquisition-focused financing is often nonexistent.

Private equity firms bring certainty of funds, repeatable deal structures, and familiarity with transactions. Operators make decisions in the field, with crews and customers in front of them. Financial buyers make decisions in spreadsheets, often hundreds of miles from the nearest jobsite.

We see this play out time and time again: the best-funded buyer frequently wins, regardless of leadership fit.

The Tradeoffs of Selling to Private Equity

Private equity is designed to maximize financial returns. That design produces both benefits and real tradeoffs.

Liquidity is a clear advantage. Founders can step back financially and reduce personal risk after years of having their net worth concentrated in a single business.

The tradeoffs of this route, though, tend to emerge after the sale. Investment horizons tend to be shorter than the natural life cycle of a trade business. Cultural priorities often shift toward financial metrics and aggressive growth targets, favoring expansion over craftsmanship and durability. Employees usually feel these changes first through altered incentives, reporting requirements or leadership turnover.

Founder reputation rarely exists cleanly. In many communities, the business remains associated with its original owner long after its sale. When post-sale outcomes decline, that association persists.

The Most Logical Exit That Rarely Happens

In most trade businesses, the most credible next owner is already inside the building and running the business long before a deal is finalized.

These general managers, superintendents and long-tenured field leaders carry institutional knowledge, the trust of the crew, and customer relationships that cannot be replaced, making them the people founders most often trust to carry the business forward.

Their decision-making under pressure has been tested repeatedly. They’ve made calls with crews short-staffed, equipment down, weather working against them and customers waiting for answers. These aren’t theoretical successors. They’re already accountable when things go wrong.

Their reputation is already tied to the company’s performance. Founders trust these leaders because cultural continuity feels natural and accountability remains clear.

Building a Business That Lasts Beyond the Founder

Succession planning should begin earlier than what feels comfortable. Waiting until retirement narrows options and increases risk. Price represents only one dimension of a successful exit. In most cases, talent isn’t the issue. Structure and support are.

Operators are asked to move from running the business to owning it without the financial tools, governance systems or transition runway required for success.

Founders benefit from evaluating successors based on decision-making under pressure, leadership credibility with crews, and the ability to grow responsibly rather than aggressively. The best operators understand there are limits on capacity, hiring, and growth and respect them.

Hybrid approaches work when ownership transfers alongside responsibility, not all at once. Ownership doesn’t need to transfer all at once. Binary thinking in this process limits outcomes. Employees, customers and founder reputation deserve protection throughout the transition.

The most successful succession plans balance liquidity, continuity and accountability. Ownership design matters as much as ownership transfer.

The Final Act of Leadership

Every founder eventually has to decide who they would trust to make the calls if they weren’t there tomorrow. An owner’s exit represents a final act of leadership with long-term consequences. Values are tested when incentives collide.

The most successful successions align ownership with responsibility rather than price alone. Trade businesses endure when transitions are intentional and accountability remains intact.

The real crisis facing the trades is not consolidation or competition. The deeper question is whether the next generation of ownership will be chosen solely by capital or by those best equipped to carry the work forward.


Wil Fry is the founder and CEO of American Operator, a firm that keeps trade businesses locally owned and operated by transitioning them to the next generation of capable operators.

Share this post :

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Pinterest

Stay close to the industry.

CCR updates, digital magazines, events, and partner insights.

Current Issue — CCR #10

Editorial & Third-Party Content Notice: Articles, press releases, company announcements, and accompanying media (including photography, graphics, and video) published on this site may be provided by third-party contributors, PR representatives, or wire sources as cited. Authorship and original copyrights remain with their respective holders.

Commercial Construction & Renovation is a registered service provider under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA). To submit an inquiry, copyright claim, or formal takedown request, you may view our registered agent listing and official contact details via the U.S. Copyright Office DMCA Designated Agent Directory, or contact our compliance desk directly at publisher@ccr-mag.com.

Receive the CCR 2024 Idustry Report

Get ahead of your Competitors with CCR's FREE Industry Insider's Report 2024!

Always stay two steps ahead of your Competitors. Stay informed with the latest in the Industry. 

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

This site uses cookies to ensure that you get the best user experience. By choosing “Accept” you acknowledge this and that ccr-mag.com operates under the Fair Use Act. Furthermore, Changing privacy laws now require website visitors from EEA based countries to provide consent in order to use personalized advertising or data modeling with either Google Ads & Analytics. Find out more on the Privacy Policy & Terms of Use Page and our Editorial & DMCA Notice.