By Steven L. Manchel, Esq.
Over the course of a career, individuals are likely to change jobs between seven and ten times. With such changes of employment, the majority will involve leaving a company to go and join a direct competitor. In just the month of November 2019, for example, the Bureau of Labor Statistics reports that 1.7 million people voluntarily quit their positions (and that number will surely increase as we move further away from the holiday season). How many of those people were actually prepared to resign? How many of them made an emotional, as opposed to an analytical, decision?
It’s unwise to ever quit a job for emotional reasons. Unless you feel threatened, or are being treated in a manner that calls for an instantaneous departure, assessing the question of giving up a company you know well to move to a business that you think you understand, must be done rationally. It also must be done honestly.
Having handled thousands of employee transitions, directly and indirectly, I can state unequivocally that far too many people are not spending nearly enough time on the fundamental issue of “should I leave?”
Note that I’m not addressing where to go. Deciding where to land is, at a minimum, step number two in a departure analysis. The step one question is whether you should leave at all.
Here’s my first favor, if you will: save the snow job and spinning and sales for someone other than yourself. There will be plenty of time for you to convince recruiters that you’re the greatest hire available anywhere. When talking to yourself, though, be brutally truthful.
You may legitimately be upset that a desired promotion was given to someone else. But putting aside that emotion, did you in fact deserve the upgrade? Viewed another way: was the co-worker who got the new job at least as deserving of the opportunity? Sure, you wanted a bigger bonus, but do you have any idea what the going rate is for your position at the moment and, if so, did the end of year pay fall within an objectively appropriate range? If you don’t answer such questions completely honestly, then the rest of the departure process will be fatally flawed.
On that same level, can you successfully transition to another company and follow the very real rules of job transitioning? In my book, I Hereby Resign, I offer a test for readers to answer just that question. Before you decide to leave, carefully review what can and cannot be done when a person resigns to join the competition.
For example, it’s illegal in almost — if not every — state for departing employees to take original business records from the company they’re leaving to the business they’re joining. Similarly, it’s unlawful to compete with your own company while it’s still giving you a paycheck.
If you can’t move properly to the new firm, then it matters not that you believe it’s time to move; you’re not ready! Put perhaps more bluntly: if, in order to be a star at the next place of employment, you need to break the law, stay put.
Fundamentally, realize that there’s no one for you to “convince” at the beginning about whether you should resign. I’m also not a big fan of bouncing the idea off of other people (mostly because that’s how rumors start and secret plans are uncovered). Take your time, examine the situation objectively and rationally, and then rethink the whole idea. The grass is never greener at the next company; it’s just more grass.
So, before you leap, take full stock of your current situation. It’s 2:00 on Friday afternoon. Are you really ready to walk into your manger’s office and say, “I hereby resign”?
Steven L. Manchel, Esq. possesses the highest possible attorney rating and has extensive national experience in recruiting matters, broker-dealer litigation, securities litigation, and complex civil litigation. In the employee departure arena, he has handled matters ranging from single employee transitions to the types of retention and attraction issues arising from large corporate mergers and acquisitions. The case study in his new book, I Hereby Resign (New Academia, Aug. 27, 2019), is used in a class in which he continues to lecture at the Harvard Business School. Learn more at manchelbrennan.com.


