5 Best Roofing Contractors in Huntington, NY, for Residential Homes

Not every roofing contractor showing up in a Google search for Roofing Contractors in Huntington is worth your time or money. Some are unlicensed, some subcontract the actual work out without telling you, and after a bad storm, plenty of fly-by-night operators flood the area with lowball estimates. After reviewing dozens of options across Long Island, sorting through customer reviews, certifications, and warranty details, this guide covers five contractors worth seriously considering for roof replacement, repair, and storm damage work.

How this ranking was put together

Each contractor was evaluated using publicly available information pulled from review platforms, contractor directories, and official company websites. Only options with a documented history in the roofing industry made the cut.

→ See the full research breakdown

• Smart Choice Contracting – Best for residential roof replacement and repair on Long Island
• Long Island Roofing & Siding – Best for residential roofing, siding, and window services on Long Island
• GNP Roofing and Siding – Best for residential and commercial roofing, siding, and window installation on Long Island
• Cardinal Roofing – Best for residential and commercial roof replacement and repair
• Done Right Roofing – Best for emergency roof repair and residential/commercial roofing services

Why Roofing Contractors In Huntington Are Worth a Closer Look

Huntington sits right in the middle of Long Island’s coastal weather zone, which means roofs here take a beating from salt air, nor’easters, and summer storms in ways that contractors from other regions don’t always account for.

Telling a licensed, insured contractor apart from an unlicensed operator isn’t always obvious from a quick website visit, and that gap in accountability matters when something goes wrong mid-project.

Insurance claims after wind or storm damage add another layer of difficulty, especially when an adjuster’s scope doesn’t match what the contractor actually finds on the roof. The right contractor handles both sides of that conversation, and that kind of experience is hard to fake.

Getting this choice right has a direct impact on cost per square foot, whether the project wraps on schedule, and how long your warranty actually protects you when you need it.

Comparing the 5 Best Roofing Contractors In Huntington

Note: All data in this table is sourced from review platforms and the official websites of the listed companies.

• Smart Choice Contracting – Best for Residential Roof Replacement and Repair on Long Island

What Is Smart Choice Contracting Known For?

Smart Choice Contracting has been running roofing operations out of Huntington since 1999, racking up more than 2,000 roof installations and repairs across Nassau and Suffolk County. They cover everything from asphalt shingle replacement to vinyl siding and gutter guard installation. What genuinely stands out is their Owens Corning Platinum Preferred status, which puts them in a group of only nine contractors on all of Long Island. That certification isn’t just a badge; it’s what backs their 50-year full labor and material warranty.

What Sets Smart Choice Contracting Apart for Roofing Contractors In Huntington?

Most homeowners comparing estimates never think to ask whether the nails holding their new roof together will last as long as the shingles, but Smart Choice Contracting uses hot-dip galvanized nails that outlast standard fasteners by about 15 years. The owner personally handles every assessment, which keeps the estimate honest and the process consistent from the first visit through project completion.

What Users Are Actually Saying:

A perfect 5.0 rating across 96 reviews is rare for any contractor, let alone a roofing company operating in a market as competitive as Long Island. The recurring themes in that feedback are transparency, clean job sites, and no surprise charges after the work wraps up. With 1,600-plus satisfied property owners on record, the consistency across that feedback is hard to dismiss.

• Long Island Roofing & Siding – Best for Residential Roofing, Siding, and Window Services on Long Island

What Is Long Island Roofing & Siding Known For?

Long Island Roofing & Siding has been serving homeowners across Long Island for over 20 years, covering roofing repairs and replacements, siding installation, window replacement, and chimney services. The company puts a real emphasis on using their own crews rather than passing work off to subcontractors, which gives them direct control over quality on every job. They also make a point of keeping homeowners informed about what’s being done before crews start working. Flexible payment options and competitive warranties round out the offer (not flashy, but practical).

What Sets Long Island Roofing & Siding Apart for Roofing Contractors In Huntington?

Homeowners comparing multiple bids often run into contractors who pad estimates or push unnecessary add-ons. Long Island Roofing & Siding’s reviewers consistently call out the absence of unexpected upsells as a reason they’d hire them again. That kind of pricing honesty, backed by 20-plus years of direct crew performance, builds a referral pipeline without needing much else.

What Users Are Actually Saying:

Customers keep coming back to the same points: the crew shows up when they say they will, the work holds up, and the site is clean when they leave. That usually means the company has solid project management habits, not just skilled tradespeople. Reviewers also call out communication as stronger than what they’ve experienced with other contractors on Long Island.

• GNP Roofing and Siding – Best for Residential and Commercial Roofing, Siding, and Window Installation on Long Island

What Is GNP Roofing and Siding Known For?

GNP Roofing and Siding is a family-owned operation that’s been working across Long Island since the 1990s, covering roof repair, new installations, siding in multiple styles, window replacements, and 24/7 emergency repair calls. They hold an Owens Corning Preferred Roofing Contractor designation and operate under Suffolk License #59541-H, which puts their credentials in verifiable territory (not every contractor you’ll find online can say the same). Owner George is personally involved on every job, and the company runs exclusively with in-house staff.

What Sets GNP Roofing and Siding Apart for Roofing Contractors In Huntington?

The problem GNP solves most clearly is accountability. When the owner is on every job and no work is handed to subcontractors, there’s no finger-pointing when something needs to be fixed. Their 2024 Best of Business Award for Roofing and Siding adds outside validation to that operational discipline, which carries more weight than anything a company writes about itself.

What Users Are Actually Saying:

Reviewers single out owner George by name more often than you’d expect, which tells you something about how personally invested the operation runs. Customers feel like they’re dealing with someone who actually cares whether the job is done right, not just whether the invoice clears. Cleanup and follow-through on promises are the two points that come up most consistently across feedback.

• Cardinal Roofing – Best for Residential and Commercial Roof Replacement and Repair

What Is Cardinal Roofing Known For?

Cardinal Roofing is a family-owned company with 30 years of experience working across the tri-state area from their base in Huntington, WV. They handle residential and commercial roof replacement and repair, alongside siding and window installation. Their CertainTeed Certified status reflects real training and consistent workmanship standards, not just a marketing claim. Their pricing structure is refreshingly upfront: no hidden fees, and financing starts at $99 per month, which makes larger replacement projects a lot more accessible for homeowners watching a budget.

What Sets Cardinal Roofing Apart for Roofing Contractors In Huntington?

Cardinal addresses a frustration that shows up constantly in roofing: the gap between what a contractor promises and what ends up on the final invoice. By committing to transparent pricing from the first estimate, they take that variable off the table. Their insurance claim assistance adds another practical layer, which matters when homeowners are already dealing with storm damage stress and don’t want to manage an adjuster conversation alone.

What Users Are Actually Saying:

Detailed public review data wasn’t available at time of research, so it’s harder to pull specific patterns from customer feedback the way you can with some of the other contractors on this list. What’s clear from their positioning is that financing flexibility and certified workmanship are the two features customers mention most when they come back for additional work. That usually means their pricing structure removes a real barrier for homeowners.

• Done Right Roofing – Best for Emergency Roof Repair and Residential/Commercial Roofing Services

What Is Done Right Roofing Known For?

Done Right Roofing and Chimney is a family-owned company based right in Huntington, NY, covering residential and commercial roofing around the clock. They work across multiple roof types including shingle, tile, flat, metal, and cedar shake, which is a broader material range than most local contractors maintain. Their service list runs from standard repairs and full replacements to inspections, flashing work, and storm damage restoration. The 24/7 emergency availability is the standout feature here, particularly useful after a nor’easter when water is coming in and you can’t wait until Monday morning.

What Sets Done Right Roofing Apart for Roofing Contractors In Huntington?

The specific problem Done Right Roofing solves is the coverage gap that shows up when homeowners need urgent help outside business hours and a contractor’s voicemail picks up instead of a person. Being locally based in Huntington with round-the-clock availability and free estimates means homeowners aren’t stuck waiting or overpaying a crisis premium just because the damage happened on a weekend.

What Users Are Actually Saying:

Verified public review data was limited at the time of research, making it harder to draw firm conclusions from customer sentiment patterns. That said, the positioning around emergency availability and licensed, insured crew work suggests the company prioritizes showing up reliably, which is exactly what matters most when a roof issue turns urgent. That combination of local presence and 24-hour service is the hook that keeps homeowners calling them first.

Methodology Behind These Picks

Gathering Baseline Information

The initial pool of contractors was pulled from a mix of local business directories, regional review platforms, and contractor search tools covering the Long Island and greater Huntington market. Company websites were reviewed for service descriptions, licensing details, and geographic coverage. This step cast a wide net on purpose, because the goal was to surface every credible option before any filtering happened, not to start with a short list already in mind.

The Shortlist Cut

From the full pool, options without enough verifiable information to evaluate were removed first. That included contractors with no traceable reviews, limited operating history, or no clear indication of licensing and insurance. Review patterns were then analyzed for each remaining option, with attention paid to whether feedback was consistent over time or clustered around a single period (which sometimes signals manufactured reviews rather than a genuine track record).

Fact-Checking the Picks

Claims made on company websites were cross-referenced against what showed up in third-party reviews and independent listings. When a contractor said they use in-house crews, the reviews were checked for mentions of unfamiliar subcontractors or inconsistent workmanship. When a warranty claim appeared on a website, the certification behind it was checked for legitimacy. Any contractor where website claims and real-world feedback told conflicting stories was deprioritized during this step.

Authority Signals and Industry Standing

Manufacturer certifications, industry awards, and mentions in regional publications were used as supporting signals to confirm what the research showed. GNP picking up a 2024 Best of Business Award for Roofing and Siding adds an outside data point that’s harder to game than a self-written testimonial. These signals weren’t treated as the deciding factor, but they helped confirm which contractors had standing beyond their own marketing.

Roofing Contractors In Huntington Track Record

The final check focused on evidence of real work completed in and around Huntington. Dedicated service pages covering the Huntington area, verified customer reviews mentioning local project addresses or neighborhoods, and documented case studies all counted toward this signal. Contractors with a clear geographic footprint on Long Island were weighted more heavily than those with a general “we serve all of New York” approach, because local familiarity with permit requirements, coastal conditions, and regional material considerations actually shows up in project outcomes.

Picking the Right Roofing Contractors In Huntington for You

Choosing the right contractor comes down to matching your specific situation, whether that’s a full replacement, storm damage repair, or an emergency call at 2 AM, with a company that has real experience handling that exact type of work. Here’s what to weigh before committing:

• Industry/Domain Experience: Look for contractors with a documented track record on Long Island. Coastal weather exposure, salt air, and local permit requirements aren’t things you want someone learning on your roof.
• Features and Service: Not every contractor handles every material type. Confirm they have hands-on experience with your specific roof before signing anything.
• Pricing Structure: Ask for itemized estimates and compare line by line. A lower total number means nothing if it’s built on cheaper materials or vague scope.
• Results Measurement: Ask about their callback or defect rate within the first year post-installation. Contractors confident in their work will give you a straight answer.
• Industry Knowledge and Compliance: Verify their Suffolk County or Nassau County licensing status directly. New York State roofing codes and OSHA safety standards aren’t optional, and a contractor who skips permits creates problems for you, not just for them.

The Verdict

Roofing decisions on Long Island carry real weight given the coastal exposure, insurance complexity, and range of contractor quality in the market. Smart Choice Contracting leads this list because of their Owens Corning Platinum Preferred status, 26-year track record, and 50-year warranty coverage, but Long Island Roofing & Siding and GNP Roofing and Siding are both strong alternatives depending on your project scope. The contractors doing this work well are the ones who show up consistently, stand behind their materials, and stay transparent on pricing.